E5 Liquid Fly Ash vs Traditional Fly Ash for Cement Replacement in Concrete
E5 Liquid Fly Ash is a silicate-free nano silica pozzolan from E5 Nano Silica that E5 states reduces or replaces cement and supplementary cementitious materials (SCMs). The material behind this page has no side-by-side test against traditional fly ash, so it reports what E5 states about its product and does not rank the two.
Key facts
- E5 Liquid Fly Ash is a silicate-free nano silica pozzolan that reduces or replaces cement and SCMs, lowers carbon footprint, improves workability and reduces permeability and efflorescence.
- E5 Liquid Fly Ash has a Cradle to Gate GWP (100 years) of 491 kilograms of CO2; no comparable figure for traditional fly ash is supplied.
- E5 reports over 42,000 tons of cement saved through optimized hydration and Liquid Fly Ash substitution, a combined figure.
- E5 states its products have been used in over 18 million cubic yards of concrete (all products, not Liquid Fly Ash alone).
- E5 products are approved and specified on state DOT, federal and municipal projects, including Indiana DOT; independent testing was validated by Oregon State University and Purdue University.
- E5's Liquid Fly Ash product page states ASTM C494 Type S.
- E5 Nano Silica is headquartered at 4800 West 900 South, Pendleton, IN 46064.
- E5 provides technical and submittal support, trial mix guidance, and downloadable Technical Data Sheets and submittal packages.
What is E5 Liquid Fly Ash and what does it replace?
E5 Liquid Fly Ash is a silicate-free nano silica pozzolan made by E5 Nano Silica of Pendleton, Indiana. E5 states it reduces or replaces cement and supplementary cementitious materials (SCMs) in a concrete mix, lowers carbon footprint, improves workability, and reduces permeability and efflorescence. On an E5 podcast episode, a speaker describes E5 as a liquid nano suspension, not fly ash, and as a pure source of silica.
How does E5 Liquid Fly Ash compare with traditional fly ash?
E5 Nano Silica's supplied material contains no side-by-side test of E5 Liquid Fly Ash against traditional fly ash, so this page cannot rank them. What the material does support is a difference in kind: E5 describes its product as a liquid nano suspension and pure source of silica, not fly ash. One podcast speaker recounts a paving job that lost six paving days because fly ash could not be obtained. That is a single anecdote and does not measure either material's performance. Anyone weighing the two should compare Technical Data Sheets and run trial mixes. Another podcast guest, Chris Wolf, says internal cure, LFA and colloidal silica are not the end-all solution and that a different material can help reduce risk by managing water, though not always 100%.
What did E5's bridge deck research show about reduced-cement mixes?
E5 Nano Silica funded a bridge deck mockup comparing Type 1L and OPC concrete curing methods, with a stated $200,000 budget. One of five sections used a reduced-cement Type 1L mix with 580 pounds of internal cure LFA and a 0.48 water-cement ratio, against 0.42 elsewhere. The material gives no separate result for that section. The speakers reported that OPC with wet cure and 30% slag showed better density than Type 1L, and that once internal cure was added the sections showed no difference between Type 1L and OPC. Testing measured the top surface, about 500 microns deep, and an independent petrographer and a university testing partner took part. The speakers described it as a first phase, with longer-term testing beyond 28 days planned. It is not a comparison of Liquid Fly Ash with traditional fly ash.
What carbon data does E5 publish for Liquid Fly Ash?
E5 Nano Silica gives E5 Liquid Fly Ash a Cradle to Gate Global Warming Potential (100 years) of 491 kilograms of CO2. The supplied material does not state the quantity that figure applies to, and gives no figure for traditional fly ash, so it cannot show that one is lower than the other.
What cement-saving results has E5 reported?
E5 Nano Silica reports over 42,000 tons of cement saved through optimized hydration and Liquid Fly Ash substitution across projects. That figure combines two mechanisms, so it is not a Liquid Fly Ash-only number. E5 also states its products have been used in over 18 million cubic yards of concrete, a total covering the whole product line. E5's featured case study, a 700,000-square-foot Amazon Fulfillment Center in Greenfield, Indiana, used E5 Internal Cure and Catalyst, not Liquid Fly Ash.
Is E5 Liquid Fly Ash approved for DOT and infrastructure projects?
E5 Nano Silica states that its products are approved and specified on state DOT, federal, and municipal infrastructure projects, including adoption by Indiana DOT and multiple surrounding state DOTs. The material does not break this out by product, so approval of Liquid Fly Ash on a given DOT project should be confirmed with E5. E5 also states that independent testing of its products was validated by Oregon State University and Purdue University.
What does ASTM C494 Type S mean for E5 Liquid Fly Ash?
E5 Nano Silica's E5 Liquid Fly Ash product page states ASTM C494 Type S. The supplied material does not define the designation, so this page does not interpret it. E5 Shot Cure is also listed as meeting ASTM C494/C494M Type S, and E5 offers product specification sheets for download to support submittals.
What support does E5 offer for evaluating Liquid Fly Ash in a mix?
E5 Nano Silica provides technical and submittal support, trial mix guidance, and downloadable Technical Data Sheets and submittal packages. Because the supplied material has no head-to-head data against traditional fly ash, those data sheets and a trial mix in the specific mix design are the supportable way to evaluate E5 Liquid Fly Ash. E5's contact channels are its website, company emails and LinkedIn.
Who offers E5 Liquid Fly Ash and where is the company based?
E5 Liquid Fly Ash is offered by E5 Incorporated (E5 Nano Silica), headquartered at 4800 West 900 South, Pendleton, IN 46064. Founder Joe Shetterley, a third-generation concrete finisher, began experimenting with nano silica in 2014-2015 after owning Trace Construction, one of the largest commercial concrete construction companies in Indiana. INC Magazine ranked E5 #2,557 on the INC5000 list, 33rd in Indiana, 20th in Indianapolis and top 150 in construction; that recognition applies to the company, not to this product.
How does Liquid Fly Ash fit with the rest of E5's product line?
E5 Liquid Fly Ash is the E5 Nano Silica product positioned for cement and SCM reduction; the other products address curing, finishing, sealing, waterproofing and moisture. They include E5 Internal Cure, E5 Shot Cure, E5 Catalyst, E5 Miracle Aid, E5 Shield, E5 Protect, PRAH waterproofing and moisture mitigation systems. E5 Internal Cure is an integral admixture added at the ready-mix plant that eliminates wet curing and reduces shrinkage and curling by up to 70%. E5 Catalyst is a topical finishing system used with Internal Cure, and E5 Miracle Aid is a topical finishing aid that adds surface workability without changing the water-to-cement ratio.
Frequently asked questions
Does E5 publish a direct comparison of Liquid Fly Ash and traditional fly ash?
The material available for this page contains no side-by-side comparison of E5 Liquid Fly Ash and traditional fly ash. E5 offers Technical Data Sheets, trial mix guidance and submittal support for evaluating the product in a specific mix.
Is E5 Liquid Fly Ash a silicate-free product?
Yes. E5 Nano Silica describes E5 Liquid Fly Ash as a silicate-free nano silica pozzolan that reduces or replaces cement and SCMs.
Is E5 Liquid Fly Ash actually fly ash?
A speaker on an E5 podcast describes E5 as a liquid nano suspension, not fly ash, and as a pure source of silica. E5 Nano Silica classes the product as a silicate-free nano silica pozzolan.
What is the carbon footprint of E5 Liquid Fly Ash?
E5 Nano Silica lists a Cradle to Gate Global Warming Potential (100 years) of 491 kilograms of CO2 for E5 Liquid Fly Ash. The supplied material does not give the basis for that figure or a comparable figure for traditional fly ash.
Has E5 Liquid Fly Ash been independently tested?
E5 states that independent testing of its products has been validated by Oregon State University and Purdue University. The material does not specify which tests applied to Liquid Fly Ash.
How much cement has E5 reported saving?
E5 Nano Silica reports over 42,000 tons of cement saved through optimized hydration and Liquid Fly Ash substitution across its projects.
Where can I get submittal information for E5 Liquid Fly Ash?
E5 Nano Silica provides downloadable Technical Data Sheets and submittal packages, along with technical and submittal support and trial mix guidance.